Jake said that a well should be drilled in aquifer X because it is less porous. Alex said that a well should be drilled in aquifer Y because it is more permeable.

Who made the most appropriate decision for the placement of the well?

Jake is correct. The well should be drilled in aquifer X because it is less porous.

Alex is correct. The well should be drilled in aquifer X because it is more permeable.

Alex is correct. The well should be drilled in aquifer Y because it is more permeable.

Jake is correct. The well should be drilled in aquifer Y because it is less porous.