-Argumentative Constructed Response with Counterclaim--Refutation for “I am Very Real” by Kurt Vonnegut—1973 criteria Student has analyzed in detail how an author's ideas or claims are developed and refined by particular sentences, paragraphs, or larger portions of a text. (RI5) Student has evaluated the argument and specific claims in the text. (RI8) The student identified the counterclaim. Student has assessed whether the reasoning is valid. (RI8). The student refuted the counterclaim. Student has assessed whether the evidence is relevant and sufficient. (RI8). The student explained the evidence.