Core english language ans 10 b (prescriptive)

which sentences would be effective thesis statements for a paragraph evaluating an argument? select two options.
hollembeak's review of the high school's play is fun and entertaining to read.
mcardle reviews the latest production of hamlet, which sets the play's action in the 21st century.
in her editorial, mellie writes convincingly of the need for high school classes to begin later in the morning,
smith's argument in favor of tuition-free college education offers persuasive reasoning and authoritative evidence.
after the flooding in her state, the junior senator offered a heartfelt plan for increasing restrictions on carbon emissions.

The best effective thesis statements are both the first ("Hollembeak's review of the high school's play is fun and entertaining to read") and third ("In her editorial, Mellie writes convincingly of the need for high school classes to begin later in the morning") options.

Explanation:

The first and third statements are the only ones which state a convincing thesis about an argument. Both of them are informative about what is the object argued and present a clear idea of the main point made on that. Second option does not apply to the question because it is lacking in some way, because though it is informative and sets an idea of the argument, it is very broad to state "the play's action [is] in the 21st century". Fourth option does apply to the question as well because it is not a thesis, that is just exploring the content of an argument made, clarifying ideas for readers. And fifth option does not apply to the question too, because it is not a thesis, that is just a description of an information previously given, it only characterizes an informative statement, not an effective thesis.

nominative

so is this a rhetorical question?