Brett Marshall was the wrong choice to play Detective Ford in On the Loose. To begin with, the novel describes Detective Ford as being “in his mid-30s with a short, stocky build.” Marshall, however, is almost 50 years old and over six feet tall. Argument 2:

Brett Marshall was the wrong choice to play Detective Ford in On the Loose. Not only did director Jim Valasquez choose the wrong actor, but he also chose the wrong location. The novel is set in “an idyllic New England town,” but Valasquez shot the movie in New Mexico.
Which argument is supported by relevant evidence, and how?

A.
Argument 2, because the example supports the claim that the director chose the wrong location to film the movie
B.
Argument 2, because the example supports the claim that the wrong actor was chosen to play Detective Ford
C.
Argument 1, because the example supports the claim that the wrong actor was chosen to play Detective Ford
D.
Argument 1, because the example supports the claim that the director chose the wrong location to film the movie