Which statement provides a critique of the central idea?

Critique refers to the detailed assessment of the given idea. In this case, the central idea is about how people in Utopia cared about the common good. The statement that serves as a critique for this is the first statement. Since it mentioned about the common good, this means that they give priority to the most needy and they provide them with their necessities. 

Look at the passages where the author describes the isolation and insanity that dr frankenstein has