What if the Madagascar Plan had been put into effect? Would it have succeeded or have eventually been a disaster as well?

Madagascar Plan was a plan to swept Jews out of Europe.

Explanation:

The advancing success in the 1940s gives Germany the opportunity to solve the Jewish question in Europe.  The Nazi company introduced an outrageous strategy to exile European Jews to the island of Madagascar. The Germans propose to reimburse the French colonists who were then living there, and then proceed to forcefully transfer Jews.

If the plan would have been succeeded it would be dominated the lives of Jews to eternity. The plan was not just to exile jews from Europe to hold them, hostage at the island under the Nazi forces.

can't without checkbox

it was certainly a debatable decision, mainly because it was based primarily on political - and not on legal or social - views. since the congress at that time was led by members of the republican party, and the territory that the tribes wanted to turn into an exclusively indian state was predominantly democratic, the proposal (as expressed in the constitution) did not succeed, but the constitution itself proved to be of crucial importance in the creation of the state of oklahoma, and, most importantly, it guaranteed the involvement of representatives of the indian tribes in the government of the future joint state.  

as a member of congress, i would have voted to ratify the constitution, or at least to have it tabled. ignoring it was an interested and partial decision.