The diagram below shows a light ray from a pencil hitting a mirror.

An upright pencil sits to the left of a mirror, which is convex facing left. An arrow from the tip of the pencil runs to the center of the mirror. Line 1 runs from the point reflection at an acute angle below the first arrow. Arrow 2 runs at an acute angle above the first arrow. Arrow 3 runs perpendicularly up from the point reflection. Arrow 4 runs through the mirror down at an obtuse angle pointing toward a distant point on a line running from the base of the pencil.

Which ray shows the correct direction of the reflected ray?

A: 1
B: 2
C: 3
D: 4