Give me a rating on these edits are they good or bad?

I'm an editor and tbh these seem very starter like, they are simple and easy to make since you just add overlays but if you're a beginner then it's understandable.

I'm gonna be brutally honest(pls don't be offended) but I think that they are a 4. Ngl though- I am horrible at edits so... yeah. I can't rly relate if this is hard. (I don't even know the first thing ab them- lol)

Explanation:

i don't know the answer but i play video games

satin. 

"very shiny satin may look great in the fabric store or in the sewing room, but once onstage it can look fake and cheap as it reflects the light from the fixtures."